Judging Merit – Article by Patrick S. Shin

From Volume 78, Number 1 (November 2004)
DOWNLOAD PDF

In their provocative article, Professors Choi and Gulati make various claims advocating the selection of the next Supreme Court Justice on the basis of “merit.” The ingenious statistical tournament (the “Tournament”) they have designed purports to identify a set of judges-“a merit-worthy pool”‘ of candidates, as they put it-who should be given privileged consideration for future vacancies on the Court.


 

78_137